The Anchoring Trap: A Hidden Influence on Your Decision-Making
The Anchoring Trap is a potent cognitive bias that subtly influences our decisions. It occurs when people consider a particular value for an unknown quantity before estimating it. This bias can lead us to give disproportionate weight to the first piece of information we receive, setting the stage for potential decision-making pitfalls.
Experience the Anchoring Trap: A Team Exercise
If you want to see just how potent the Anchoring Trap can be, try this exercise with your team:
- Divide your team into two groups.
- Group 1: Give them a piece of paper with the following questions: a. Is the population of Australia more or less than 20 million? b. What is the population of Australia?
- Group 2: Give them a piece of paper with the following questions: a. Is the population of Australia more or less than 75 million? b. What is the population of Australia?
- Collect the answers from both teams and average their responses. You will find that the average estimation by Group 2 is significantly higher than that of Group 1.
This simple exercise vividly illustrates how the Anchoring Trap can affect our decision-making processes. It highlights our tendency to anchor our judgments to the initial information we encounter, even when it lacks relevance or accuracy.
The Anchoring Trap in Everyday Life
Marketers, salespeople, and lawyers are well aware of the Anchoring Trap’s power and frequently use it to manipulate us through advertisements, sales pitches, and negotiations. However, its impact is not confined to these areas. The Anchoring Trap can influence virtually every brainstorming activity, hindering our ability to think creatively and generate innovative solutions.
Consider your team’s brainstorming sessions. The first idea presented often serves as an anchor for the rest of the discussion, limiting the team’s creativity and its capacity to explore alternative problem-solving approaches. This dynamic directly affects the second step in the Decision-Making Framework (DMF) — generating creative alternatives.
The Solution: Breaking Free from Anchors
So, how can you mitigate the Anchoring Trap’s influence and empower your team to think more independently and creatively? Here’s a solution:
- Start by sharing your carefully framed Opportunity Statement at the beginning of your collaboration session. Developing your Opportunity Statement is the first step in the DMF.
- Rather than immediately diving into a discussion about capturing the opportunity, have each team member take a few minutes to write down their ideas independently. This initial step prevents team members from prematurely anchoring on and being influenced by others’ ideas.
- Once everyone has their ideas on paper, go around the room and have people share what they’ve written down. This approach allows for a more open and diverse exchange of ideas, unfettered by the Anchoring Trap’s influence.
By recognizing and actively addressing the Anchoring Trap, you can foster a more creative, open, and effective decision-making process within your team.
Learn More About Decision-Making Framework
Are you interested in enhancing your team’s decision-making abilities in the face of complexity and uncertainty? You can watch our webinar, where we provide an overview of the Decision-Making Framework, explore common decision traps, and share best practices.
Let’s Discuss Strategies for Empowering Your Team
Would you like to delve deeper into strategies for empowering your team to make better decisions? Use this link to schedule a conversation with us. There’s no cost involved.
By recognizing and actively addressing the Anchoring Trap, you can foster a more creative, open, and effective decision-making process within your team.
#enablingempowerment #decisionmaking #leadership #empoweremployees #culturechange
Chris Seifert is the founder of Enabling Empowerment and an operations leader with 25+ years of experience managing high-risk, complex manufacturing operations and advising senior executives on strategy, leadership, culture, and execution. Most recently, Chris led Enviva Biomass’s manufacturing operations, first as VP HSEQ and then VP Operations, during a 6-year period in which revenue grew from $450MM to >$1B, plant production increased by >200% through commissioning new assets, integrating acquisitions, and organic growth, while reducing safety incident rates by more than 85% and growing adjusted EBITDA by >250%. As a Partner at Wilson Perumal and Company, Chris founded and grew an Operational Excellence Consulting Practice and became recognized internationally as a leading expert on Operational Excellence (OE), Operational Discipline (OD), and Operational Excellence Management Systems (OEMS). Chris has also served as a Plant Manager for Georgia Pacific and Owens-Corning and as a Supply Officer in the US Navy Nuclear Submarine Force.
